Shopify App

How to Use Social Proof to Increase Conversions on Shopify

How to Use Social Proof to Increase Conversions on Shopify

Ever wondered why you’re more likely to try a restaurant with a line outside than an empty one? Or why you check reviews before buying something online? That’s social proof in action – and it could be the missing piece in your Shopify store’s conversion puzzle.

Did you know that 92% of consumers read online reviews before making a purchase? Or that displaying customer testimonials can increase conversions by up to 34%? These aren’t just random statistics – they’re proof that people trust other people more than they trust brands.

In this guide, you’ll learn:

  • What social proof is and why it works so well
  • The different types of social proof you can use in your Shopify store
  • Step-by-step instructions for implementing each type
  • How to measure the impact of your social proof strategies
  • Advanced techniques to take your conversions to the next level

Ready to turn browsers into buyers? Let’s dive in!

Understanding the Psychology Behind Social Proof

Before we jump into the “how,” let’s understand the “why.” Social proof works because humans are social creatures who look to others when making decisions, especially in uncertain situations.

Social Proof Psychology Visual

The Psychological Foundations

When shopping online, customers can’t touch or try products before buying. This creates uncertainty. To overcome this, they look for signals that indicate whether a purchase is “safe” or “good.” This is where social proof comes in – it shows that others have taken the leap before them and had a positive experience.

Think about it: when was the last time you bought something online without checking reviews? Probably not recently. That’s because we’ve all developed this decision-making habit as online shoppers.

Consumer Behavior and Social Proof

Here’s what the research tells us about how social proof influences buying decisions:

  • 92% of consumers read online reviews before making a purchase
  • Shoppers are willing to spend 31% more on a business with excellent reviews
  • FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out) drives impulse purchases when customers see others buying or enjoying products
  • Social proof helps reduce perceived risk, making customers more comfortable with their purchase

Now that we understand why social proof is so powerful, let’s explore the different types you can implement in your Shopify store. Which one will become your secret conversion weapon? Let’s find out!

Types of Social Proof for Shopify Stores

Not all social proof is created equal. In this section, we’ll explore the different types you can use in your Shopify store, along with their unique benefits.

Social Proof for Shopify Stores

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Reviews and star ratings are perhaps the most common form of social proof – and for good reason. They provide direct feedback from people who have already purchased your product.

Studies show that products with reviews are 270% more likely to be purchased than products without reviews. And the impact of star ratings is huge – moving from a 3-star to a 5-star rating can increase conversions by up to 84%.

But don’t worry about getting only perfect reviews. A mix of positive and negative reviews actually increases credibility. In fact, products with only 5-star reviews are often viewed with suspicion!

User-Generated Content (UGC)

UGC includes customer photos, videos, and social media posts featuring your products. This type of content is incredibly powerful because it shows your products in real-world situations.

For example, a fashion brand might display customer photos showing how different people style their clothes. This not only builds trust but also helps potential customers visualize the product in their own lives.

Brands that incorporate UGC into their product pages see an average 29% increase in conversion rates. That’s a significant boost for a relatively simple implementation!

Expert Reviews and Testimonials

Endorsements from industry experts or influencers can significantly boost your credibility. When someone with authority in your niche recommends your product, it carries more weight than a regular customer review.

This can be especially effective for technical products or items where expertise matters. For example, a skincare brand might feature endorsements from dermatologists, while a tech store might showcase reviews from tech experts.

Social Media Proof

Displaying your social media following and engagement can show potential customers that you have an active community around your brand. This can include:

  • Follower counts
  • Social media feeds embedded on your site
  • Share counts on your products
  • Comments and interactions from social platforms

We’ve explored the main types of social proof, but which one should you implement first? Customer reviews are often the easiest starting point, so let’s dive deeper into how to collect and display them effectively!

Implementing Customer Reviews and Ratings

Customer reviews are the foundation of social proof for most Shopify stores. Here’s how to collect and display them effectively.

Customer Reviews and Ratings Visual

Review Collection Strategies

The first challenge is getting customers to leave reviews. Here are some effective strategies:

  1. Post-purchase email sequences: Send an automated email 7-14 days after delivery asking for a review.
  2. Incentives: Offer a small discount on future purchases in exchange for a review.
  3. Make it easy: Keep the review process simple with clear instructions and minimal clicks.
  4. Follow up: If customers don’t respond to your first email, send a gentle reminder a few days later.

The timing of your review request is crucial. Asking too early means customers haven’t had time to use the product, while asking too late means their excitement has faded.

Review Display Optimization

Once you have reviews, it’s important to display them effectively:

  • Show star ratings prominently on product pages, ideally above the fold
  • Include a review summary showing the breakdown of ratings
  • Allow customers to filter reviews by rating, date, or helpful votes
  • Feature review excerpts on your homepage and collection pages
  • Add photo and video reviews when possible

Verified Buyer Badges

Marking reviews as “Verified Purchase” increases their credibility. Studies show that verified reviews are considered 15% more trustworthy than unverified ones.

Make sure your review system clearly indicates which reviews come from confirmed buyers. This simple badge can significantly impact trust levels.

Shopify Apps for Reviews

Several Shopify apps make implementing reviews easy:

  • Judge.me (Rated 5/5): Comprehensive review solution with photo/video reviews
  • Loox: Focuses on photo reviews with easy implementation
  • Rivyo: Offers Q&A features alongside reviews
  • Ali Reviews: Good for dropshipping stores

Reviews are powerful, but they’re just one piece of the social proof puzzle. Want to take things to the next level? Let’s look at how to leverage user-generated content to create an even stronger connection with potential customers!

Leveraging User-Generated Content

User-generated content (UGC) is authentic, relatable, and highly influential. Here’s how to make it work for your Shopify store.

UGC Collection Strategies

Encouraging customers to share content featuring your products requires a strategic approach:

  1. Create a branded hashtag and promote it on packaging, inserts, and emails
  2. Run photo contests where customers share images using your products
  3. Send post-purchase emails specifically requesting photos or videos
  4. Offer incentives like features on your social media or small discounts
  5. Make sharing easy with clear instructions and mobile-friendly upload options

For example, the skincare brand Jolie Skin Co asks customers to share photos of their shower routines with the hashtag #MyJolieRoutine, then features these images on their product pages.

Displaying UGC on Product Pages

Once you have customer content, here’s how to display it effectively:

  • Create a gallery section on product pages showing customers using the product
  • Include before/after photos when relevant (especially effective for skincare, fitness products, etc.)
  • Add customer quotes alongside their photos for additional context
  • Ensure UGC is mobile-optimized, as most shopping happens on phones

Shoppable UGC

Take UGC to the next level by making it shoppable! This means customers can click on user photos and be taken directly to the featured products.

According to studies, shoppable UGC can increase conversion rates by up to 15% compared to non-shoppable content. It creates a seamless path from inspiration to purchase.

UGC Curation and Moderation

Not all user content is created equal. To maintain quality:

  • Establish clear guidelines for what content you’re looking for
  • Review submissions before publishing them on your site
  • Focus on diverse content that shows different uses or people
  • Regularly refresh your UGC to keep it current

UGC builds authentic connections with potential customers, but sometimes you need a little extra push to create urgency. That’s where social proof notifications come in – let’s see how they can drive immediate action!

Implementing Social Proof Notifications

Social proof notifications are those small pop-ups that appear while you’re browsing a store, showing recent purchases, live visitor counts, and more. They create a sense of activity and urgency that can drive conversions.

Recent Sales Notifications

These notifications show when someone has recently purchased a product. They work because they:

  • Create a sense that others are actively buying (the store is trustworthy)
  • Generate FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out)
  • Make the store feel busy and popular

For best results:

  • Show real purchase data (fake notifications can damage trust)
  • Include the buyer’s location to add credibility
  • Display notifications subtly in the corner of the screen
  • Set a reasonable frequency (too many notifications become annoying)

Visitor Count Indicators

Showing how many people are currently viewing a product creates a sense of competition and urgency. This works particularly well for popular items.

For example: “15 people are currently viewing this product” suggests that the item might sell out soon, encouraging faster decision-making.

Stock Level Indicators

Low stock indicators (e.g., “Only 3 left in stock!”) create scarcity, which is a powerful psychological trigger for purchase decisions.

These indicators work best when:

  • They’re based on actual inventory levels
  • They appear near the add-to-cart button
  • They create urgency without causing anxiety

Customization and Branding

To ensure notifications enhance your store rather than distract from it:

  • Match notification design to your brand (colors, fonts, tone)
  • Ensure they’re mobile-responsive
  • A/B test different styles and messages
  • Allow customers to close notifications if they find them distracting

Several Shopify apps make implementing these notifications easy, including:

  • Qikify Social Proof (Rated 4.9/5)
  • Urgency Bear
  • FOMO

Notifications create urgency, but customers also need reassurance that your store is safe and trustworthy. Let’s look at how trust badges and certifications can provide that peace of mind!

Trust Badges and Certifications

Trust badges and certifications are visual symbols that reassure customers your store is legitimate, secure, and trustworthy. They address key concerns that might prevent purchases.

Payment Security Badges

Security concerns are one of the top reasons for cart abandonment. Payment badges help overcome this by showing that customer data is protected.

Effective uses include:

  • Displaying SSL certificate badges to show secure connections
  • Showing payment processor logos (PayPal, Visa, Mastercard, etc.)
  • Adding McAfee, Norton, or other security service badges

The most effective placement is in the checkout flow, particularly near credit card entry fields. This provides reassurance exactly when customers need it most.

Industry Certifications

Depending on your products, industry-specific certifications can build significant trust:

  • Organic or Non-GMO for food products
  • Cruelty-Free or Vegan for cosmetics
  • Fair Trade for coffee, chocolate, or textiles
  • Energy Star for appliances

Display these prominently on product pages and explain what they mean if the certification isn’t widely recognized.

“As Seen In” Media Mentions

If your brand or products have been featured in media outlets, creating an “As Seen In” section can significantly boost credibility.

For example, Spacegoods displays logos of publications that have featured their products in the footer of every page. This creates instant recognition and trust by association.

Trust Badge Apps

Several Shopify apps can help you implement trust badges:

  • Trust Badge Bear (Rated 4.9/5): Offers customizable trust badges
  • Free Trust Badge: Simple but effective free option
  • Trust Hero: Includes A/B testing features

Trust badges create the foundation of credibility, but highlighting popular products can drive even more sales. Let’s explore how product popularity indicators can help customers find your best offerings!

Product Popularity Indicators

Product popularity indicators show customers which items are most popular, trending, or frequently purchased together. They leverage social proof while also helping customers discover your best products.

Bestseller Badges

Adding a simple “Bestseller” badge to popular products can increase their conversion rates by up to 35%. These badges work because:

  • They reduce decision fatigue by highlighting proven choices
  • They create confidence in the quality of the product
  • They make customers feel they’re making a “safe” choice

Implement bestseller badges on collection pages and in search results to guide customers toward popular items early in their shopping journey.

“Frequently Bought Together” Sections

Showing products that are often purchased together serves two purposes:

  • It increases average order value
  • It shows that other customers found these combinations valuable

This strategy works especially well for:

  • Complementary products (shampoo + conditioner)
  • Accessories for main products (phone + case)
  • Refills or replacements (razor + blades)

Customer Purchase Counters

Displaying how many times a product has been purchased (e.g., “Over 5,000 sold”) creates powerful social proof. It shows that many others have trusted this product.

This works best for products with impressive sales numbers. If an item has only sold a few units, it’s better to use other social proof methods instead.

Trending Product Indicators

Unlike bestsellers (which show long-term popularity), trending indicators highlight what’s popular right now. They create a sense of being current and in-the-know.

Trending indicators work well:

  • On your homepage to highlight new, popular items
  • In email marketing to drive traffic to hot products
  • During seasonal periods when shopping behaviors shift

Popular products create their own momentum, but sometimes you need an extra push from someone influential. Let’s see how influencer and celebrity endorsements can take your social proof to the next level!

Influencer and Celebrity Endorsements

Influencer and celebrity endorsements leverage the trust and admiration people have for public figures. When someone influential recommends your product, their credibility transfers to your brand.

Leveraging Influencer Content

Working with influencers doesn’t have to mean partnering with mega-celebrities. Micro-influencers (typically 10,000-50,000 followers) often have highly engaged audiences and can be more affordable and effective.

To leverage influencer content effectively:

  • Choose influencers whose audience matches your target market
  • Repurpose influencer content on your product pages and social media
  • Create dedicated landing pages for influencer collaborations
  • Add influencer testimonials to relevant products

Celebrity Endorsements

If celebrities use your products, make it known! Fitness brand Whoop effectively showcases professional athletes who use their product, creating instant credibility in the fitness community.

If you don’t have celebrity customers, alternatives include:

  • Sending free products to relevant celebrities
  • Creating affiliate partnerships with public figures
  • Highlighting any media coverage that mentions celebrities using similar products

Expert Testimonials

Industry experts can be even more influential than celebrities for certain products. For example:

  • A dermatologist’s endorsement for skincare products
  • A professional chef’s recommendation for kitchen tools
  • A trainer’s testimonial for fitness equipment

Expert testimonials work best when they include specific details about why the expert recommends the product. This adds credibility and helps customers understand the product’s benefits.

Influencer-Generated Content

When repurposing influencer content on your site:

  • Always get proper permission and rights
  • Maintain context about how the influencer uses the product
  • Keep content authentic rather than overly promotional
  • Update regularly to keep it fresh and current

Influencers help build trust on your website, but what about reaching customers through email? Let’s explore how to leverage social proof in your email marketing efforts!

Social Proof in Email Marketing

Email marketing remains one of the most effective channels for e-commerce, with an average ROI of $42 for every $1 spent. Adding social proof to your emails can make them even more powerful.

Review Integration in Emails

Including reviews in marketing emails helps overcome objections before customers even visit your site. Effective approaches include:

  • Adding star ratings next to product images
  • Including review quotes from satisfied customers
  • Creating dedicated review roundup emails for popular products
  • Segmenting emails to show reviews relevant to customer interests

For example, if a customer has viewed skincare products on your site, send them an email featuring reviews specifically for those products.

UGC in Email Campaigns

User-generated content in emails feels authentic and creates an emotional connection. Consider:

  • Including a “Customer Gallery” section in newsletters
  • Creating “See how others are using it” campaigns
  • Featuring customer success stories with photos
  • Highlighting before/after images when relevant

Social Proof in Abandoned Cart Emails

Abandoned cart emails have an average recovery rate of about 10%. Adding social proof can push that number even higher:

  • Include star ratings for the abandoned products
  • Add “Customers also bought” recommendations
  • Incorporate urgency elements like “10 people bought this since you viewed it”
  • Feature a brief testimonial about the abandoned product

Post-Purchase Social Proof

After a purchase, social proof helps reduce buyer’s remorse and encourages repeat purchases:

  • Send “Join the X happy customers” messaging in confirmation emails
  • Share how others are using the purchased product
  • Include complementary products with their reviews
  • Invite customers to join the community of users on social media

Email tools like Klaviyo integrate seamlessly with Shopify, making it easy to incorporate social proof into your email campaigns.

We’ve covered many strategies, but how do you know if they’re actually working? Let’s look at how to measure the impact of your social proof efforts!

Measuring the Impact of Social Proof

Implementing social proof strategies is just the beginning – measuring their impact is crucial for optimization. Here’s how to track the effectiveness of your social proof elements.

Key Performance Indicators

Track these metrics before and after implementing social proof:

  • Conversion rate: The percentage of visitors who make a purchase
  • Average order value: How much customers spend per order
  • Add-to-cart rate: The percentage of visitors who add products to cart
  • Bounce rate: The percentage of visitors who leave without taking action
  • Time on site: How long visitors spend browsing your store

For the most accurate measurements, track these metrics by traffic source and device type.

A/B Testing Strategies

A/B testing allows you to compare different approaches and identify what works best. Test elements such as:

  • Placement of reviews on product pages
  • Types of social proof (reviews vs. UGC vs. testimonials)
  • Quantity of reviews displayed (3 vs. 10 vs. all)
  • Format of social proof notifications

Keep tests simple by changing only one element at a time, and run them for at least 2 weeks to gather sufficient data.

User Behavior Analysis

Beyond conversion metrics, analyze how users interact with social proof elements:

  • Use heat mapping to see if users are engaging with social proof elements
  • Track click rates on reviews, UGC galleries, etc.
  • Analyze scroll depth to see if users are viewing social proof sections
  • Conduct user testing to gather qualitative feedback

ROI Calculation

Calculate the return on investment for your social proof implementations:

  1. Measure increase in conversions after implementation
  2. Calculate the additional revenue generated
  3. Subtract the cost of implementation (app fees, design work, etc.)
  4. Divide the net gain by the cost to get your ROI

For example, if implementing reviews costs $500 in apps and design work but generates an additional $5,000 in sales, your ROI is 900%.

Now that you know how to measure success, let’s explore some advanced strategies to take your social proof to the next level!

Advanced Social Proof Strategies

Ready to take your social proof beyond the basics? These advanced strategies can help you stand out from competitors and squeeze even more conversions from your store.

Personalized Social Proof

Tailoring social proof to individual visitors can significantly increase its impact. Consider:

  • Showing reviews from similar customers (e.g., “People in your age group loved this product”)
  • Displaying location-based social proof (“Popular in [Customer’s City]”)
  • Highlighting reviews related to previously viewed products
  • Customizing social proof based on traffic source (e.g., different testimonials for visitors from Facebook vs. Google)

Personalized social proof requires more advanced technology but can increase conversion rates by up to 30% compared to generic social proof.

Social Proof Sequencing

Different types of social proof work better at different stages of the customer journey. Consider this strategic sequence:

  1. Homepage: Overall store ratings and trust badges
  2. Category pages: Bestseller badges and popularity counters
  3. Product pages: Detailed reviews and customer photos
  4. Cart page: Security badges and satisfaction guarantees
  5. Checkout: Last-minute reassurance with security icons

This approach addresses different customer concerns as they move through the purchasing process.

Combining Multiple Proof Types

Different customers respond to different types of social proof. By combining multiple types, you can appeal to a broader audience:

  • Pair expert testimonials with customer reviews to balance authority and peer feedback
  • Combine sales notifications with stock counters to create both social validation and urgency
  • Use UGC galleries alongside star ratings to appeal to both visual and data-driven shoppers
  • Display media mentions next to customer counts for third-party validation

The key is to find complementary proof types that reinforce each other without overwhelming visitors.

Localized Social Proof

If you sell internationally, localized social proof can significantly boost conversions:

  • Translate reviews into the visitor’s language
  • Show reviews from customers in the same country or region
  • Display local currency in pricing and reviews when possible
  • Highlight region-specific certifications or awards

Studies show that localized social proof can increase conversions by up to 40% in international markets compared to generic social proof.

Advanced strategies can give you an edge, but sometimes it’s helpful to see real examples. Let’s look at some successful case studies to inspire your own implementation!

Case Studies and Examples

Learning from successful Shopify stores can provide valuable insights for your own social proof strategy. Here are some real-world examples that demonstrate effective implementation.

Successful Shopify Social Proof Implementations

Case Study 1: The Skincare Company

A skincare brand struggled with conversion rates below 1.5% despite high-quality products. They implemented a comprehensive social proof strategy:

  • Added verified customer reviews with before/after photos
  • Displayed dermatologist testimonials on key products
  • Created an Instagram gallery showing real results
  • Added subtle “12 people bought this in the last 24 hours” notifications

Results: Conversion rates increased to 3.8% (153% improvement), and average order value increased by 22% as customers bought recommended product combinations.

Case Study 2: The Home Goods Store

A home goods retailer found that customers were hesitant to purchase furniture online without seeing it in person. Their solution:

  • Created a “Real Homes” gallery with customer photos of products in use
  • Added detailed reviews focusing on quality and comfort factors
  • Implemented a Q&A section where existing customers could answer prospective buyers’ questions
  • Added “As Featured In” logos from home decor magazines

Results: Cart abandonment decreased by 28%, and returns dropped by 14% as customers had more accurate expectations of products.

Industry-Specific Approaches

Different industries benefit from different social proof strategies:

Fashion and Apparel

  • Focus on customer photos showing styling options
  • Highlight size and fit information in reviews
  • Use Instagram galleries and influencer content
  • Implement “Complete the Look” recommendations

Electronics and Gadgets

  • Emphasize technical expert reviews
  • Display detailed product ratings on specific features
  • Highlight compatibility information from customers
  • Use video reviews showing products in action

Food and Beverages

  • Focus on taste testimonials and customer photos
  • Highlight health certifications prominently
  • Show “frequently bought together” bundles
  • Feature chef endorsements when possible

These examples show how different brands have tailored social proof to their specific products and audience needs. Now, let’s create an implementation plan to put these strategies into action for your store!

Implementation Guide

Ready to put social proof to work in your Shopify store? This step-by-step implementation guide will help you get started, prioritize your efforts, and avoid common pitfalls.

Step-by-Step Implementation Plan

Phase 1: Foundation (Weeks 1-2)

  1. Audit your current social proof: Evaluate what you already have and identify gaps
  2. Set up a review collection system: Install a review app and create automated email sequences
  3. Add trust badges: Implement payment security and basic trust indicators
  4. Set up analytics: Ensure you can measure the impact of your changes

Phase 2: Expansion (Weeks 3-4)

  1. Start collecting UGC: Create a hashtag and begin requesting customer photos
  2. Implement social proof notifications: Add recent purchases and visitor count indicators
  3. Add product popularity indicators: Implement bestseller badges and purchase counters
  4. Integrate reviews into emails: Add reviews to marketing and cart recovery emails

Phase 3: Optimization (Weeks 5-8)

  1. Analyze performance data: Identify which social proof elements are most effective
  2. A/B test placement and formatting: Optimize how social proof is displayed
  3. Expand to advanced strategies: Consider personalization and combined approaches
  4. Refine and scale: Double down on what works, remove what doesn’t

Tools and Resources

Recommended Shopify Apps:

  • Reviews: Judge.me (5/5), Loox (4.9/5), Ali Reviews (4.8/5)
  • UGC: Foursixty (4.8/5), Instafeed (4.7/5)
  • Social Proof Notifications: Qikify (4.9/5), Urgency Bear (4.8/5)
  • Trust Badges: Trust Badge Bear (4.9/5), Free Trust Badge
  • Product Badges: Flair (5/5), Ultimate Special Offers (4.9/5)

Measurement Tools:

  • Shopify Analytics: Basic tracking for conversions and sales
  • Google Analytics: Deeper insights into customer behavior
  • Hotjar: Heat mapping and session recording
  • Lucky Orange: Visitor recordings and conversion tracking

Common Implementation Challenges:

  • Limited reviews at first: Focus on getting reviews for bestsellers first, then expand
  • Low-quality UGC: Provide clear guidelines and examples of what you’re looking for
  • Technical limitations: Consider hiring a Shopify expert for complex implementations
  • Overwhelmed visitors: Start with a few key elements and add more gradually

Remember, social proof implementation is not a one-time project but an ongoing process of collecting, displaying, and optimizing customer feedback and experiences.

Conclusion

Social proof is not just a marketing tactic—it’s a fundamental aspect of human decision-making that you can leverage to build trust, reduce uncertainty, and boost conversions in your Shopify store.

We’ve covered a lot in this guide:

  • The psychological foundations that make social proof so effective
  • Different types of social proof from reviews to influencer endorsements
  • Implementation strategies for each social proof element
  • Measurement approaches to optimize your results
  • Advanced techniques to stay ahead of competitors

The most successful Shopify stores don’t just sell products—they build communities of satisfied customers who proudly share their experiences. By strategically implementing social proof throughout your customer journey, you can transform browsers into buyers and buyers into advocates.

Remember that social proof works best when it’s authentic. Focus on providing excellent products and customer service, and the positive social proof will follow naturally.

Ready to get started? Begin with the foundation: set up a review collection system, add basic trust elements, and measure your results. Then gradually expand and refine your approach based on what works for your specific audience and products.

Want to take your Shopify store’s growth even further? With Growth Suite, you can implement social proof strategies alongside other powerful conversion optimization tools. Try Growth Suite today to maximize your Shopify store’s sales potential!

References

Muhammed Tüfekyapan
Muhammed Tüfekyapan

Founder of Growth Suite & The Conversion Bible. Helping Shopify stores to get more revenue with less and fewer discount with Growth Suite Shopify App!

Articles: 72

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts